Posts

BMI test unsuited to males with anorexia | Letter

Denying people with eating disorders help until their body mass index is low enough is particularly dangerous for male patients, writes one parent

The chair of the Royal College of Psychiatrists is concerned that people with eating disorders in England are denied help until their body mass index is “low enough” (Report, 5 April). The situation is even worse than you report, because at least a tenth of anorexia nervosa sufferers are male. They have lower fat reserves, and their irreducible skeleton is a larger proportion of their body weight. Starvation is therefore quicker to affect their muscles and vital organs.

In our city, the criterion for hospital admission is a BMI of 14. This seems to be based on experience with young women. Our GP was trying to get our son into hospital for five weeks. Our son was unable to sit up or cough, and had significant renal and liver impairment; he was at death’s door. Only when his BMI reached 14 was he taken to hospital for two months’ physical stabilisation. He then spent six months in a specialised eating disorders unit (60 miles away, as our city had no male beds for anorexia).

Continue reading...
A year of emotional eating? Don’t feel guilty. We need comfort, not ketosis | Emma Beddington

Many of us will leave lockdown a few pounds heavier than we started it, but there is no shame in finding pleasure in food

You know how people fill online baskets with clothes they never buy? I do that now with food. I see something advertised, compile an extravagant order, then don’t follow through. In the past few weeks, I have almost ordered hand-pulled noodles, oysters and something described as a “pistachio black forest gateau” (I am still thinking about that one).

It’s a new iteration of emotional eating, still apparently my main hobby and way of marking the passage of time. Friday is pizza, Saturday is jumbo Hula Hoops, Easter Sunday was fistfuls of Mini Eggs, anticipated then enjoyed with the abandon of one of the worst Roman emperors. Most evenings, my husband and I stand in the kitchen rationalising that it’s perfectly reasonable to have what he calls “a proper apéritif” (he means crisps with our drinks, but wants to sound sophisticated).

Continue reading...
A year of emotional eating? Don’t feel guilty. We need comfort, not ketosis | Emma Beddington

Many of us will leave lockdown a few pounds heavier than we started it, but there is no shame in finding pleasure in food

You know how people fill online baskets with clothes they never buy? I do that now with food. I see something advertised, compile an extravagant order, then don’t follow through. In the past few weeks, I have almost ordered hand-pulled noodles, oysters and something described as a “pistachio black forest gateau” (I am still thinking about that one).

It’s a new iteration of emotional eating, still apparently my main hobby and way of marking the passage of time. Friday is pizza, Saturday is jumbo Hula Hoops, Easter Sunday was fistfuls of Mini Eggs, anticipated then enjoyed with the abandon of one of the worst Roman emperors. Most evenings, my husband and I stand in the kitchen rationalising that it’s perfectly reasonable to have what he calls “a proper apéritif” (he means crisps with our drinks, but wants to sound sophisticated).

Continue reading...
People with eating disorders in England denied help as ‘BMI not low enough’

Experts warn of surge in condition in pandemic, and say patients being put in ‘life-threatening position’ to lose more weight

Growing numbers of women and men in England with eating disorders are being denied support because they are not considered to be thin enough to warrant it, a leading psychiatrist and other experts have warned in a briefing shared with ministers.

Against the backdrop of a fourfold rise in people admitted to hospital with eating disorders during the Covid pandemic, doctors said body mass index (BMI) was too often used as a blunt measure to decide whether someone should get treatment.

Related: NHS sees surge in referrals for eating disorders among under-18s during Covid

Continue reading...
People with eating disorders in England denied help as ‘BMI not low enough’

Experts warn of surge in condition in pandemic, and say patients being put in ‘life-threatening position’ to lose more weight

Growing numbers of women and men in England with eating disorders are being denied support because they are not considered to be thin enough to warrant it, a leading psychiatrist and other experts have warned in a briefing shared with ministers.

Against the backdrop of a fourfold rise in people admitted to hospital with eating disorders during the Covid pandemic, doctors said body mass index (BMI) was too often used as a blunt measure to decide whether someone should get treatment.

Continue reading...
‘My intuition told me something was wrong’: three women denied help for their eating disorders

The women who felt their eating disorders were not taken seriously by doctors tell their stories

As a personal trainer, Chloe Hodgkinson was considered the epitome of good health but when she came off the contraceptive pill, her period stopped.

Months passed and, despite her doctor saying it was normal for menstruation not to return immediately, Hodgkinson, 25, could not shake the feeling that something more was going on. “I told the doctor that I think I undereat and have a weird thought process with food,” she said. However, she said that because her body mass index (BMI) was not low she was not taken seriously.

Continue reading...
‘My intuition told me something was wrong’: three women denied help for their eating disorders

The women who felt their eating disorders were not taken seriously by doctors tell their stories

As a personal trainer, Chloe Hodgkinson was considered the epitome of good health but when she came off the contraceptive pill, her period stopped.

Months passed and, despite her doctor saying it was normal for menstruation not to return immediately, Hodgkinson, 25, could not shake the feeling that something more was going on. “I told the doctor that I think I undereat and have a weird thought process with food,” she said. However, she said that because her body mass index (BMI) was not low she was not taken seriously.

Continue reading...
Demi Lovato: Dancing With the Devil … The Art of Starting Over review | Alexis Petridis’s album of the week

Lovato delivers lacerating lyrics about the trauma she’s faced since childhood, but the music is less startling

Demi Lovato’s Dancing With the Devil … The Art of Starting Over is an album that is hard to view objectively. It arrives in the wake of a documentary series, also called Dancing With the Devil, and a subsequent broadsheet interview, both of which detailed the former Disney star’s descent into drug addiction in agonising detail. If you thought the recent Britney Spears documentary was a damning indictment of the way the music industry and media treats young female stars – and the consequences of doing so – then Lovato’s story significantly ups the ante.

Related: 'I have to keep smiling': how the female pop star documentary got real

Continue reading...
Have you accessed NHS eating disorder services during the pandemic?

We would like to hear from those who have sought help from the NHS for eating disorders

The number of people experiencing eating disorders has risen dramatically during the Covid-19 pandemic.

During a parliamentary health and social care committee meeting last week, Claire Murdoch, the NHS England director of mental health, said there had been a doubling of eating disorder referrals in the last 12 months.

Continue reading...
‘So much pressure to look a certain way’: why eating disorders are rife in pop music

A documentary series about Demi Lovato shows how brutally controlled the singer’s diet once was, and, as other pop performers attest, it’s control that underpins damaging behaviour

For eight years of her life, Demi Lovato was served a watermelon cake for her birthday. This wasn’t a watermelon-flavoured version of a proper cake with all the good stuff like butter, sugar and flour, but rather an actual watermelon with some icing on top.

The reason for this was that her team at the time were “trying to keep her weight down”, according to Lovato’s best friend Matthew Scott Montgomery, who is interviewed as part of Demi Lovato: Dancing With the Devil, the YouTube documentary series premiering this week. Her team would police what she ate, he says, and those she was with were also required to eat only when Lovato ate, with no snacking outside of meals, in an attempt to “keep her well” and avoid triggering a relapse into the restrictive eating disorders she struggled with as a teenager.

Continue reading...